From Threat to Right: Rethinking Immigration Policy Through Competing Global Paradigms

Agung Sulistyo Purnomo; Eva Achjani Zulfa; Muhammad Syaroni Rofii; Mohamad Dian Revindo

doi:10.62870/jog.v10i2.32456

From Threat to Right: Rethinking Immigration Policy Through Competing Global Paradigms

Agung Sulistyo Purnomo, Eva Achjani Zulfa, Muhammad Syaroni Rofii, Mohamad Dian Revindo

Abstract

This article critically re-examines how immigration is framed across five dominant global paradigms: security, economic utility, humanitarian obligation, cultural integration, and global mobility. Drawing on a critical interpretive synthesis of interdisciplinary literature, it unpacks the ideological, ethical, and policy logics embedded in each framework. While each paradigm offers distinct insights, the analysis reveals their internal contradictions, blind spots, and overlapping tensions. The paper argues for a pluralistic and ethically grounded approach to migration governance, one that integrates competing logics without collapsing complexity. By mapping these paradigms and their normative stakes, the study offers a conceptual toolkit for designing migration policies that are context-sensitive, morally coherent, and institutionally realistic. It contributes to a growing body of scholarship that challenges technocratic and securitarian approaches to migration, calling instead for frameworks that are attentive to justice, human agency, and global interdependence. In a world increasingly defined by mobility, inequality, and uncertainty, this article contends that rethinking immigration governance is not only possible but necessary. Through a nuanced engagement with diverse schools of thought, it seeks to enrich scholarly debate and inform principled policymaking that reflects both empirical realities and ethical imperatives.

Keywords

Immigration Policy; global justice; migration governance; pluralism; mobility rights; security; humanitarianism.

Full Text:

PDF 349-369

References

Aiyar, S., Barkbu, B., Batini, N., Berger, H., Detragiache, E., Dizioli, A., Ebeke, C., Lin, H., Kaltani, L., Sosa, S., Spilimbergo, A., & Topalova, P. (2016). The Refugee Surge in Europe: Economic Challenges. Staff Discussion Notes, 16(2), 1. https://doi.org/10.5089/9781513552590.006

Allerton, C. (2017). Contested Statelessness in Sabah, Malaysia: Irregularity and the Politics of Recognition. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies, 15(3), 250–268. https://doi.org/10.1080/15562948.2017.1283457

Anderson, B. (2013). Us and Them? The Dangerous Politics of Immigration Control. Oxford University Press.

Andreas, P. (2003). Redrawing the Line: Borders and Security in the Twenty-First Century. International Security, 28(2), 78–111.

Aradau, C., & van Munster, R. (2009). Exceptionalism and the “War on Terror”: Criminology Meets International Relations. British Journal of Criminology, 49(5), 686–701. https://doi.org/10.1093/bjc/azp036

Arendt, H. (1951). The Origins of Totalitarianism. In On Violence (New Editio). Duke University Press. https://doi.org/10.1006/abbi.1999.1419

Asis, M. M. B., & Piper, N. (2008). Researching International Labor Migration in Asia. The Sociological Quarterly, 49(3), 423–444. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1533-8525.2008.00122.x

Avdan, N. (2019). Visas and Walls: Border Security in the Age of Terorism. In Visas and Walls. University of Pennsylvania Press All. https://doi.org/10.9783/9780812295696

Bauböck, R. (2009). Global Justice, Freedom of Movement and Democratic Citizenship. European Journal of Sociology, 50(1), 1–31. https://doi.org/10.1017/S000397560900040X

Bell, D. (2017). Political realism and international relations. Philosophy Compass, 12(2), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1111/phc3.12403

Bell, D. A. (2006). Beyond Liberal Democracy: Political Thinking for an East Asian Context. Princeton University Press. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004479135_004

Benhabib, S. (2004a). Kantian Questions, Arendtian Answers: Statelessness, Cosmopolitanism, and the Right to Have Rights. In S. Benhabib & N. Fraser (Eds.), Pragmatism, Critique, Judgment Essays for Richard J. Bernstein (p. 404). The MIT Press.

Benhabib, S. (2004b). The Right of Others: Aliens, Residents, and Citizens. Cambridge University Press. www.cambridge.org

Betts, A. (2013). Survival Migration: Failed Governance and the Crisis of Displacement. Cornell University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/ijrl/eev054

Betts, A., & Collier, P. (2017). Refuge: Transforming a Broken Refugee System. Penguin Random House. https://doi.org/10.1353/scu.2020.0053

Bigo, D. (2002). Security and immigration: Toward a critique of the governmentality of unease. Alternatives, 27(SUPPL. 1), 63–92. https://doi.org/10.1177/03043754020270s105

Borjas, G. J. (2014). Immigration Economics. Harvard University Press.

Boswell, C. (2007). Migration Control in Europe After 9/11: Explaining the Absence of Securitization*. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 45(3), 589–610. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-5965.2007.00722.x

Bove, V., & Böhmelt, T. (2016). Does Immigration Induce Terrorism? The Journal of Politics, 78(2), 572–588. https://doi.org/10.1086/684679

Cainkar, L. A. (2009). Homeland Insecurity: The Arab American and Muslim American Experience after 9/11 (1st ed.). Russell Sage Foundation.

Carens, J. H. (2015). An overview of the ethics of immigration. In New Challenges in Immigration Theory (1st ed., p. 22). Routledge.

Cesari, J. (2009). Muslims in the West after 9/11: Religion, politics, and law. In D. Bigo, E. Guild, & R. B. J. Walker (Eds.), Muslims in the West after 9/11. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203863961

Costinot, A., & Donaldson, D. (2012). Ricardo’s Theory of Comparative Advantage: Old Idea, New Evidence. In NBER Working Paper (17969; JEL No. F11,Q11,Q15,Q17,R14). Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-25984-5_301698

Czaika, M., & De Haas, H. (2011). The effectiveness of Immigration Policies A Conceptual Review of Empirical Evidence. In The IMI Working Papers Series (33; 3, Issue 33). www.migrationdeterminants.eu

De Genova, N. (2014). Spectacles of migrant “illegality”: The scene of exclusion, the obscene of inclusion. In The Language of Inclusion and Exclusion in Immigration and Integration (1st ed., p. 19). Routledge.

Dentico, N. (2021). The Breathing Catastrophe: COVID-19 and Global Health Governance. Development, 64(1–2), 4–12. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41301-021-00296-y

Denyer, D., & Tranfield, D. (2009). Producing a systematic review. In D. A. Buchanan & A. Bryman (Eds.), The Sage handbook of organizational research methods (pp. 671–689). Sage Publications Ltd.

Dixon-Woods, M., Agarwal, S., Jones, D., Young, B., & Sutton, A. (2005). Synthesising qualitative and quantitative evidence: a review of possible methods. Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 10(1), 45–53. https://doi.org/10.1258/1355819052801804

Docquier, F., & Rapoport, H. (2011). Globalization, Brain Drain and Development. In Journal of Development Economics (5590; IZA Discussion Papers). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdeveco.2012.11.002

Dowd, R., & McAdam, J. (2017). Inernational Cooperation and Responsibility-Sharing to Protect Refugees: What, Why and How? International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 66(4), 863–892. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020589317000343

Dustmann, C., & Frattini, T. (2014). The Fiscal Effects of Immigration to the UK. The Economic Journal, 124(580), F593–F643. https://doi.org/10.1111/ecoj.12181

Dzordzormenyoh, M. K., & Boateng, F. D. (2023). Immigration Politics and Policymaking in the USA (2017–2021): Examining the Effect of Geopolitics on Public Attitude Towards Immigration Policies. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 24(3), 1281–1303. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-022-01004-6

Esposito, F., & Bosworth, M. (2024). Gender, Violence and Regimes of Vulnerability in Immigration Detention. In Immigration Detention and Social Harm (pp. 137–154). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003370727-11

Fassin, D. (2012). Humanitarian Reason: A Moral History of the Present. University of California Press. http://www.ucpress.edu/book.php?isbn=9780520271173

Feigenberg, B. (2020). Fenced Out: The Impact of Border Construction on US-Mexico Migration. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 12(3), 106–139. https://doi.org/10.1257/app.20170231

FitzGerald, D. S. (2019). Refuge beyond Reach: How Rich Democracies Repel Asylum Seekers. Oxford University Press.

Freeman, G. P. (1995). Modes of immigration politics in liberal democratic states. International Migration Review, 29(4), 881–913. https://doi.org/10.2307/2547729

Guild, E. (2010). The European Union after the Treaty of Lisbon: Fundamental Rights and EU Citizenship. Centre for European Policy Studies, May 2010, 9.

Haas, H. de, Castles, S., & Miller, M. J. (2015). The Age of Migration: International Population Movements in the Modern World. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 38(13), 2355–2355. https://doi.org/10.1080/01419870.2015.1050048

Helbling, M., & Meierrieks, D. (2022). Terrorism and Migration: An Overview. British Journal of Political Science, 52(2), 977–996. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007123420000587

Hollifield, J. F., Martin, P. L., Orrenius, P. M., & Héran, F. (2022). Controlling Immigration. In J. F. Hollifield, P. L. Martin, P. M. Orrenius, & F. Héran (Eds.), Controlling Immigration: A Comparative Perspective (4th ed.). Stanford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1515/9781503631670

Hugo, G. (2002). Effects of international migration on the family of Indonesia. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 11(1), 13–46. https://doi.org/10.1177/011719680201100102

Huysmans, J. (2006). The Politics of Insecurity Fear, migration and asylum in the EU. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.7202/017058ar

Joppke, C. (2004). The retreat of multiculturalism in the liberal state: theory and policy. The British Journal of Sociology, 55(2), 237–257. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-4446.2004.00017.x

Kang, S., & Song, B. K. (2022). Did Secure Communities Lead to Safer Communities? Immigration Enforcement, Crime Deterrence, and Geographical Externalities. The Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 38(2), 345–385. https://doi.org/10.1093/jleo/ewab013

Kim, D., & Tajima, Y. (2022). Smuggling and Border Enforcement. International Organization, 76(4), 830–867. https://doi.org/10.1017/S002081832200011X

Kukathas, C. (2005). Language Rights and Political Theory. Perspectives on Politics, 3(01). https://doi.org/10.1017/S1537592705280143

Kukathas, C. (2014). The Case for Open Immigration. In A. I. Cohen & C. H. Wellman (Eds.), Contemporary Debates in Applied Ethics (2nd ed., p. 376). John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Kymlicka, W. (1996). Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights (paperback). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/0198290918.001.0001

Kymlicka, W. (2012). Multiculturalism: Success, Failure, and the Future. In Migration Policy Institute.

Lang, I. G. (2024). Security-centric approach in the use of digital technologies in EU migration and asylum policies. Transnational Legal Theory, 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1080/20414005.2024.2399934

Lewis, H., Dwyer, P., Hodkinson, S., & Waite, L. (2015). Hyper-precarious lives. Progress in Human Geography, 39(5), 580–600. https://doi.org/10.1177/0309132514548303

Malkki, L. H. (1996). Speechless Emissaries: Refugees, Humanitarianism, and Dehistoricization. Cultural Anthropology, 11(3), 337–404. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203979549-17

Menjívar, C., & Abrego, L. J. (2012). Legal Violence: Immigration Law and the Lives of Central American Immigrants. American Journal of Sociology, 117(5), 1380–1421. https://doi.org/10.1086/663575

Mezzadra, S., & Neilson, B. (2013). Border as Method, or, the Multiplication of Labor. Duke University Press. https://doi.org/10.1215/9780822377542

Milner, J. (2009). Refugees and the Regional Dynamics of Peacebuilding. Refugee Survey Quarterly, 28(1), 13–30. https://doi.org/10.1093/rsq/hdp015

Minca, C., & Vaughan-Williams, N. (2012). Carl Schmitt and the Concept of the Border. Geopolitics, 17(4), 756–772. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650045.2012.660578

Morgenthau, H. J., & Thompson, K. W. (1993). Politics Among Nations: The Struggle for Power and Peace. Brief Edition (6th ed.). McGraw-Hill.

Nussbaum, M. C. (2006). Frontiers of Justice: Disability, Nationality, Species Membership. Harvard University Press.

OECD. (2017). Better Policies for Better Lives. Members and Partners. http://www.oecd.org/about/membersandpartners/

Ottaviano, G. I. P., & Peri, G. (2012). Rethinking the Effect of Immigration on Wages. Journal of the European Economic Association, 10(1), 152–197. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1542-4774.2011.01052.x

Papademetriou, D. G., & Sumption, M. (2011). Rethinking Points Systems and Employer-Selected Immigration. In Migration Policy …. http://www.migrationpolicy.org/pubs/rethinkingpointssystem.pdf

Pinotti, P. (2015). Immigration Enforcement and Crime. American Economic Review, 105(5), 205–209. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.p20151040

Rae, G. (2016). The real enmity of Carl Schmitt’s concept of the political. Journal of International Political Theory, 12(3), 258–275. https://doi.org/10.1177/1755088215591301

Rein, M., & Schön, D. (1996). Frame-critical policy analysis and frame-reflective policy practice. Knowledge and Policy, 9(1), 85–104. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02832235

Rodriguez, R. M. (2010). Migrants for Export: How the Philippine State Brokers Labor to the World. University of Minnesota Press. https://muse.jhu.edu/book/24439.

Ruhs, M. (2013). The Price of Rights: Regulating International Labor Migration. Princeton University Press.

Ruhs, M., & Martin, P. (2008). Numbers vs. Rights: Trade-Offs and Guest Worker Programs. International Migration Review, 42(1), 249–265. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1747-7379.2007.00120.x

Sager, A. (2016). Methodological Nationalism, Migration and Political Theory. Political Studies, 64(1), 42–59. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9248.12167

Schmitt, C. (2005). Political Theology: Four Chapters on the Concept of Sovereignty. The University of Chicago Press.

Sen, A. (2009). The Idea of Justice. In Journal of Human Development. The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.1080/14649880802236540

Shachar, A. (2006). The Race for Talent: Highly Skilled Migrants and Competitive Immigration Regimes (883739; UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO LEGAL STUDIES).

Taylor, C. (1994). The Politics of Recognition. In A. Guttman (Ed.), Multiculturalism: Examining the politics of recognition (p. 25). Princeton University Press.

Tazzioli, M. (2019). The Making of Migration: The biopolitics of mobility at Europe’s borders. Sage Publications Ltd.

UNHCR. (2011). The 1951 Convention and its 1967 Protocol. In UNHCR (p. 16). UNHCR.

Ypi, L. (2012). Global Justice and Avant-Garde Political Agency. Oxford University Press.

Zimbalist, Z. (2025). Regional Economic Communities and Attitudes Toward Free Cross-Border Movement in Africa. International Migration Review. https://doi.org/10.1177/01979183241303703

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.62870/jog.v10i2.32456